Scholarly Work

Penderecki's Phantom Bell

Penderecki's Phantom Bell

AMS 2021 National Conference

Penderecki’s Phantom Bell was presented at the 2021 AMS National Conference and later published on the Timbre and Orchestration Resource (TOR), a peer-reviewed open-access web platform supporting the analysis, creation and teaching of timbre and orchestration.

Penderecki has created a fascinating aural illusion in the fourth movement of his massive, powerful oratorio for Orthodox Easter Eve, Utrenja, Part I: The Entombment of Christ. In the opening seconds we hear the unmistakable sound of the resonance of a great dystonic cathedral bell. However, a look at the score tells us that there is no bell present at this moment. I will give an in-depth look at bell acoustics using Hibbert, Taherzadeh, and Sharp's work in bell pitch perception (2017 p. 55, 62) and show how Penderecki's timbral illusion not only models a bell, but a giant, imaginary Russian-style cathedral bell, as opposed to a European bell.